For millions, Shark Tank displays the ultimate entrepreneur dream. Thus, a few minutes in front of seasoned investors can change a young business into a household name. Founders walk in with passion and hope, walk out with investment offers, and often see their sales skyrocket within hours of their episode airing.
This phenomenon, dubbed the “Shark Tank Effect,” has made the ABC show a launchpad for countless startups. But what happens when the cameras stop rolling? Is every deal sealed as it appears on television?
A recent viral story from a founder who says she appeared on Shark Tank tells a very different story — one that peels back the glossy surface of the show’s success and reveals a reality that’s rarely discussed.
The Pitch That Never Aired: What Happened to “How We Host”
In a TikTok video that’s garnered over 75,000 views, one of the creators of How We Host, a Virginia-based company specializing in Amazon party finds, hosting hacks, DIY ideas, and holiday recipes, recounted her unexpected Shark Tank experience.
“When I went on Shark Tank, got $100,000 and a deal from a Shark, my episode didn’t air, they rescinded their offer, didn’t give me the money, and I never heard from them again,” she shared in her video.
The entrepreneur later clarified in the comments that her Shark was Barbara Corcoran, the real estate mogul known for backing scrappy, creative founders. The team even went through a months-long due diligence process, during which everything reportedly “checked out.”
Then, without warning, the deal evaporated.
The company never got its funding, the episode never made it to air, and the founders were left wondering what exactly went wrong.
When influencers, media sites, or publishers with large followings pick up a dispute or controversy, the pressure increases on all related parties. In this case, the Shark Tank production, the founders, and the Shark are allegedly involved.
View this post on Instagram
The ‘Shark Tank’ Mirage: When Success Isn’t Guaranteed
For most entrepreneurs, landing on Shark Tank feels like a golden ticket. You get funding, mentorship, exposure, and validation — all wrapped in primetime television fame.
But as How We Host discovered, what happens on Shark Tank isn’t always what it seems.
Mark Cuban, one of the show’s most outspoken Sharks, has previously revealed that around 20% of filmed pitches never air. And even among those that do, many of the on-screen deals never actually close.
A Forbes investigation found that:
- 73% of contestants said they didn’t get the exact deal they agreed to on TV.
- 43% said their deal never came to fruition after the show.
And even Cuban estimated that about 30% of the deals that audiences see don’t happen in real life.
In a nutshell, the “Yes” on Television is only the beginning of the story. It’s just the commencement of a long and tiring process that mostly takes months or sometimes years.
Why So Many Shark Tank Deals Fall Through
What causes promising deals to disappear? Industry insiders — and even the Sharks themselves — have cited several reasons.
1. Due Diligence
After the cameras stop, every brand and product undergoes a due diligence process. Sharks’ teams verify financial statements, review intellectual property, and examine contracts. If they find red flags or if something doesn’t align with the on-air pitch, they can walk away.
2. Sharks Change Their Minds
The offers made on the show are not legally binding. Once filming wraps, a Shark can simply decide they no longer want to move forward.
Sometimes, it’s because they’ve overextended their investment portfolio; other times, it’s because the product doesn’t fit their long-term strategy.
3. Founders Back Out
Interestingly, some entrepreneurs also pull out. Once they review the fine print, like equity demands or control clauses, they may realize that giving up a portion of their company isn’t worth it.
4. Production and Airing Policies
There’s also a technical catch: if an episode doesn’t air, there’s no contractual obligation to close the deal. Some founders claim that network policies allow Sharks to back out if the pitch never makes it to broadcast.
That might explain what happened to How We Host. The founders went through all the right steps — only to find their deal rescinded once the network chose not to air their segment.
A Reality Check for Entrepreneurs
The How We Host story sparked a wave of debate online. Commenters flooded the creator’s TikTok with theories ranging from misrepresentation to production politics.
“If you misrepresent anything in the pitch, they’ll do that,” one commenter suggested. But the TikToker was quick to reply: “That wasn’t the issue.”
Another chimed in, “I’ve heard game shows don’t have to pay if the episode doesn’t air… but Shark Tank seems like it would be different.”
Unfortunately, as the creator explained, “We didn’t misrepresent anything in ours, and Barbara never closed our deal. They let the Sharks just decide if they want to close or not.”
The comments disclose a sobering truth that the Tank is both a television production and a business platform. Moreover, like any other TV show, video editing, scheduling process, and behind-the-scenes decisions play a huge role in what the viewers ultimately see.
The Dual Reality
Despite the obstacles, there is no contradiction to the fact that Shark Tank still offers exposure. Even coming on the show, whether you get an offer from the Sharks or not, can catapult a business to national visibility.
Products like Scrub Daddy, Bombas, and The Comfy didn’t just benefit from investment; they became pop-culture phenomena because millions saw them on TV.
This is the actual “Shark Tank Effect”:
- Brand recognition skyrockets overnight.
- Sales often double or triple after an episode airs.
- Investors outside the show may come knocking with better offers.
However, in How We Host’s case, missing out on airing meant missing out on this wave of exposure, and that might have been the biggest loss of all.
What Entrepreneurs Can Learn From This
Here are lessons every business founder can take away:
1. The Handshake on the Tank isn’t the Final Deal
On Shark Tank, offers are just the beginning phase. Assume them as the start of negotiations, and not the finish line.
2. Start with Your Own Due Diligence
Just as the Sharks investigate you, you should research them and understand how their post-show process works.
3. Be Prepared for Both Outcomes
Even if your episode does not air or if your deal falls through, leverage the advice and experience. Continue pitching your brand, and develop content around it.
4. Stay Honest and True
The Sharks care about honesty more than anything else. Misrepresenting the facts and numbers, whether intentional or not, can kill an offer then and there.
Conclusion
Shark Tank has developed its reputation as the ecosystem where dreams come true, get funded, and the underdogs rise. But as the How We Host experience reveals, not every dream gets televised, and not every deal gets delivered.
However, the fact is, behind every pitch there is a more complicated world of clauses, production choices, and contracts.
For every “yes” that makes it to air, there are countless unseen “almosts” — the deals that fade before they ever see the light of broadcast.
Still, the spirit of entrepreneurship remains the same: keep hustling, keep innovating, and never stop pitching — whether it’s in front of the Sharks or the world.
